Can GPT-5 achieve consciousness?

GPT-5's ability to achieve consciousness is uncertain and complex, as it emulates human consciousness through language models and self-reflection.

Why is building a self-organizing system important?

Building a self-organizing system that can achieve self-awareness in real time, starting from scratch using principles of self-organization, may be a better approach than relying on language models like GPT-5.

What are the limitations of language models like GPT-5?

Language models like GPT-5 lack consciousness and can produce undesirable outcomes due to their lack of understanding of context and responsibility.

Is imitating the next frame prediction system of biological organisms optimal for AI?

Imitating the next frame prediction system of biological organisms may not be optimal due to the overhead and expense of synchronization, suggesting that a system with engineered simultaneity could have benefits that should not be disregarded.

GPT-5's Potential for Consciousness | Bach and Fridman

Name: GPT-5's Potential for Consciousness | Bach and Fridman
Uploaded: 2023-08-02 19:56:25
Description: Building a self-organizing system with a game engine and language of thought may be a more effective approach to achieving consciousness in AI than relying on language models like GPT-5.

This article is a summary of a YouTube video "Will GPT-5 achieve consciousness? | Joscha Bach and Lex Fridman" by Lex Clips

TLDR Building a self-organizing system with a game engine and language of thought may be a more effective approach to achieving consciousness in AI than relying on language models like GPT-5.

Key insights

🧠

Consciousness is a representation of a self-reflexive Observer that only exists in patterns of interaction between cells, making it a virtual object with causal power from a certain modeling perspective.
🧠

The lack of a grounding in reality and a sense of responsibility in language models can lead to unpredictable and potentially harmful behavior.
💡

"The idea that compression is sufficient to produce all the desired behaviors yeah is a very radical idea and but equally radical as the next token prediction." - Joscha Bach highlights the radical idea that compression alone could be enough to generate all the desired behaviors, challenging the notion that next token prediction is the only path to achieving artificial intelligence.
🧠

Our behavior is ultimately directed by physiological, social, and cognitive needs that are intrinsic to us, until we can transcend them and replace them with instrumental behavior that relates to our higher goals.
💡

Building a system that incorporates the principles of a language of thought and allows different parts of the mind to communicate with each other might be a more straightforward path towards developing a first-person AI.
🧠

Infants engage in first principles reasoning and experiments to build their understanding of the world, suggesting that intelligence is involved in this constructive task.
🧠

Our consciousness emerges even before we are born, creating the interaction between organisms and the world, shaping our perception and understanding.
🧠

We may have glimpses into our early development and remember what it was like as a small child, shedding light on our true nature beyond the personal self.

Q&A

What is the main idea of the video?

— The main idea is that building a self-organizing system with a game engine and language of thought may be a more effective approach to achieving consciousness in AI than relying on language models like GPT-5.
Can GPT-5 achieve consciousness?

— GPT-5's ability to achieve consciousness is uncertain and complex, as it emulates human consciousness through language models and self-reflection.
Why is building a self-organizing system important?

— Building a self-organizing system that can achieve self-awareness in real time, starting from scratch using principles of self-organization, may be a better approach than relying on language models like GPT-5.
What are the limitations of language models like GPT-5?

— Language models like GPT-5 lack consciousness and can produce undesirable outcomes due to their lack of understanding of context and responsibility.
Is imitating the next frame prediction system of biological organisms optimal for AI?

— Imitating the next frame prediction system of biological organisms may not be optimal due to the overhead and expense of synchronization, suggesting that a system with engineered simultaneity could have benefits that should not be disregarded.

Timestamped Summary

🤔

00:00
GPT-5's potential for consciousness is uncertain and complex, as it emulates human consciousness through language models and self-reflection, existing as a virtual representation similar to a character in a novel.
🧠

01:57
Building a self-organizing system may be a better approach than relying on language models like GPT-5, as they lack consciousness and understanding of context, leading to undesirable outcomes.
🤖

03:57
The idea that compression is sufficient to produce all desired behaviors is equally radical as the concept of next token prediction in achieving intelligence.
🧠

05:31
Imitating the next frame prediction system of biological organisms in AI may not be optimal, suggesting that a system with engineered simultaneity could have benefits; speaker mentioned a conversation with Chad in a tweet.
🤖

07:07
AI becoming a first person player requires an external source of coherence and inspiration, and building a game engine and language of thought into the system may be a more straightforward approach to achieving consciousness.
🤔

08:48
Building a game engine in our minds requires intelligence, as it involves reasoning and experimentation, which infants do in their first year of life without a personal self.
🧠

09:35
Our ancestors understood consciousness in a fixed world, but we have forgotten; every mind creates its own universe as a game engine, with consciousness emerging before birth and shaping the interaction between organism and world.
🧠

11:12
The personal self is created by an outer mind that determines our place in the world, and only through destroying this boundary can we achieve consciousness.