Challenges faced by boys and men in education and social policy

Play video
This article is a summary of a YouTube video "Why men and boys are struggling | Richard Reeves" by Big Think
TLDR The video explores the structural challenges faced by boys and men in education and social policy, the importance of investing in vocational education and training, the need to update our understanding of fatherhood, the value of diverse friendships, the changing nature of marriage, and the gender pay gap, with a focus on creating a safe space for discussing controversial topics.

Social and familial issues and their impact on men's well-being

  • 🧑‍🤝‍🧑
    Boys and men are struggling and traditional methods of help don't seem to work as well for them as they do for girls and women.
  • 🧔
    Fathers matter, period: "All the evidence is that fathers matter to their children's flourishing."
  • 💔
    "Deaths of despair" such as suicide, overdose, and alcoholism are three times higher among men than women, which is a symptom of a broader malaise troubling boys and men.
  • 👨‍👦‍👦
    Men being left on the sidelines of their children's lives is contributing to the struggles of boys and men in society.
  • 🌎
    The decline of social networks and opportunities to make friends could lead to a dystopian future of isolated, sad, and lonely individuals, highlighting the importance of cultivating friendship for human flourishing.
  • 💔
    The death of marriage story is not right - there's a growing class divide in marriage, rather than the complete collapse of marriage.
  • 🤝
    The challenge is to create more stability in family life without sacrificing the goal of equality, and to focus on strong relationships and parenting rather than restoring the old model of marriage.
  • 🤝
    The role of friendship is becoming a particular challenge for men, exacerbating the problems they face in other parts of their lives.

Economic struggles and inequality

  • 💪
    Boys and men from lower-income backgrounds, working class boys and men, and Black boys and men are at the sharpest end of many of the social and economic changes of recent years.
  • 💰
    American men are poorer than they were half a century ago, with most earning less than they did in 1979, while women's earnings have risen across the board.
  • 💼
    Men with lower levels of skill and education have been hit the hardest economically, with one in three out of the labor force now.
  • 💼
    Men are facing a twin risk from both free trade and automation, which have significantly reduced the share of jobs that could be seen as the ones that were traditionally male.

Educational challenges and gender disparities

  • 🚶‍♂️
    Boys and men are struggling in education as girls and women have surpassed them in a short period of human history.
  • 🏫
    High school years turn out to be critical for adolescent development and educational performance, as high school GPA and performance really does matter for what happens to you after that.

Q&A

  • What are the challenges facing boys and men in education and social policy?

    — The video explores the structural challenges faced by boys and men in education and social policy, highlighting that the problems are structural rather than individual.

  • Why are girls outperforming boys in education?

    — Girls are outperforming boys in almost every measure of education, resulting in a wider gender gap in college degrees favoring women.

  • How has the teaching profession changed in terms of gender representation?

    — The teaching profession has become predominantly female, with only 24% of K-12 teachers being male, leading to a need for intentional efforts to recruit more male teachers.

  • What are the consequences of gender differences in brain development for education policy?

    — Gender differences in brain development have consequences for education policy, with boys being at a disadvantage due to the emphasis on "soft skills" and the ability to sit still and pay attention.

  • How has the concept of marriage changed in America?

    — The concept of marriage in America has changed significantly due to the women's movement, resulting in more freedom and choice for women, and a shift towards egalitarian principles.

Timestamped Summary

  • 📚
    00:00
    Boys and men face structural challenges in education and social policy interventions have not been effective, leading to a wider gender gap in college degrees favoring women.
  • 🧠
    08:34
    Girls' brains develop faster than boys' brains, putting them at an advantage in an education system that rewards "soft skills," but the lack of data disaggregated by sex makes it difficult to address the gender gap in high school graduation rates.
  • 💼
    18:17
    Investing in vocational education and training can help address economic challenges faced by working-class men and reduce gender and economic inequality.
  • 👨‍👧‍👦
    28:45
    The outdated model of fatherhood is contributing to male disadvantage and intergenerational struggles, and we need to update and expand our understanding of what it means to be a father.
  • 👥
    41:22
    Traditional friendships are declining due to technology and work, but it's important to recognize the value of friendship for mental and physical health, and to make intentional efforts to cultivate diverse friendships.
  • 💍
    53:10
    Marriage in America has changed with a growing class divide, a shift towards egalitarian principles, and a focus on parenting rather than romance.
  • 💰
    1:08:38
    The gender pay gap is driven by differences in occupation and caregiving responsibilities, and changes need to be made to address these issues and promote equality.
  • 👥
    1:23:42
    The author creates a safe space for discussing controversial topics with good faith disagreements, and the speaker is rethinking their beliefs on gender issues.
Play video
This article is a summary of a YouTube video "Why men and boys are struggling | Richard Reeves" by Big Think
4.8 (76 votes)
Report the article Report the article
Thanks for feedback Thank you for the feedback

We’ve got the additional info